25°FFog/MistFull Forecast

Editor's Note: In defense of a traditional read

Published: Tuesday, July 23, 2013 12:00 p.m. CST

I shared a story on Facebook about my toddler becoming rapturous over the smell of a rack of books. A friend – a voracious reader – posted the following comment:

“Books are dead and gross and not good. It’s like someone in the sixteenth century saying, ‘Books are fine but I just love the smell and feel of scrolls.’”

So I thought about that. A lot. Probably too much. And while I enjoy a good e-read – I read books on both my phone and computer regularly – I decided I’m not ready to give up my paper library just yet. And here are some reasons why:

• Books are eco-friendly. It’s not commonly known, but the paper and printing industries, in the United States at least, plant more trees than they cut down. My traditional book is not powered by a battery charged by burning fossil fuels, and when it comes to the end of its useful life, it can be reused, composted or recycled; even if it ends up in a landfill, it will biodegrade in about 15 years without leaching toxins or heavy metals into the environment.

• Books are easier to lend to friends.

• I feel more comfortable putting a $5 cardboard book into the sticky hands of my toddler than a $150 e-reader. No explanation should be necessary.

• Speaking of children’s books, a child’s brain responds differently to the multi-sensory experience of a book (feeling it, smelling it) than it does to images, even moving images, on a screen. The more senses involved, the more neural pathways the brain creates to process them.

E-books are fine, and I understand my friend’s abhorrence of the “mold, mildew and bacteria” paper can harbor. But there are some things a tablet just can’t do as well as a pile of paper pages. And I like it that way. So put me firmly on the fence between the two camps.

And whether you’re reading this in print or online, enjoy your MidWeek.

Reader Poll

Where do you do the majority of your shopping?
In DeKalb County
Outside of DeKalb County
Evenly split